U.S. Supreme Court: American Citizen Has No Right to Court Review of Denial of Husband’s Visa Application

The United States Supreme Court has decided that consular officers will continue to have broad discretion, and little outside challenge, when denying a visa application. In the case titled Kerry v. Din, Fauzia Din, an American citizen via naturalization, had married Kaniska Berashk, a citizen of Afghanistan. Berashk submitted an application with the consular office at the U.S. embassy in Islamabad, Pakistan, based on being married to a U.S. citizen. The application was denied. The consulate officer handling Berashk’s application failed to enumerate the reasons for the denial, but cited “terrorist activities,” a term with a broad definition under the Patriot Act and the 1996 Congressional immigration reform legislation.

Din brought the matter to a local federal trial court for review, arguing that she was entitled to appeal the consular officer’s decision since she was being denied her right to live with her spouse. She argued that, if the decision was upheld, she was entitled to an explanation of what the applicant had done that made him ineligible for citizenship, and the law under which he was ineligible. A federal appeals court agreed with her, holding that the consular officer had based the denial on insufficient grounds.

The Obama administration appealed this decision, arguing that applications for citizenship can be denied based on evidence that the government is not required to disclose to the applicant, and that it has absolute authority to keep non-citizens out of the country for any reason.

The Supreme Court ruled that Din did not have a right to court review of the consulate’s decision denying the visa. While the decision was split, with enough Justices siding with the Obama administration to cause Din to lose, but not all agreeing with one another on the basis for doing so, the Court essentially held that the reason that the consular officer gave her was sufficient to meet any rights that Din may have had. The four Justices who dissented with the majority reasoned that Din had a right as a U.S. Citizen to live with her husband in the U.S., and, under the Due Process clause of the Fifth Amendment, was entitled to be heard in court if that right was denied. While it seemed as though the Court might permit court challenges to consular visa denials under different circumstances in the future, for the time being, consular decisions aren’t reviewable in a court of law.

Citizenship and visa application processes are complex and overwhelming. If you or a loved one are attempting to attain a long-term visa, permanent residency, or apply for citizenship, ensure that you are prepared for the process by retaining skilled legal help. The Lozano Law Firm has the experience and flexibility to best serve your immigration law needs, with offices located in both San Antonio and San Angelo. For a consultation concerning your immigration issues, from anywhere in Texas, or throughout the US, call 210-932-3600 to get the help you deserve.

The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Sep 17, 2021,
(Translated by Google) Highly recommended. Thanks for everything. (Original) Muy recomendado. Graci...
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Sep 10, 2021,
(Translated by Google) My experience is one of total satisfaction, a great team of professionals, at...
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Sep 7, 2021,
(Translated by Google) They are VERY GOOD immigration attorneys. We have had a professional experien...
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Aug 25, 2021,
(Translated by Google) Good attention, professionalism, good price (the good costs) also very access...
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Aug 1, 2021,
Cómo contribuir para cuidar el agua. No entiendo porque sigan publicando el panorama obsesivo compu...
Facebook
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Jul 14, 2021,
(Translated by Google) Excellent Service and Follow-up, If you need advice on immigration issues, th...
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Jun 3, 2021,
Mr. Lozano is extremely kind, professional, and more importantly HUMAN! I was very anxious and conce...
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
May 25, 2021,
Law Firm Owner Alfredo Lozano and I have been in different Professional Workshops together over the ...
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Feb 13, 2021,
The Lozano Law Firm is a great resource for anyone with immigration needs. They were professional, q...
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Sep 30, 2020,
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Jun 23, 2020,
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Jun 1, 2020,
Alfredo and his staff’s services are unmatched. Friendly team, knowledgeable attorney, and dedicated...
Facebook
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Apr 28, 2020,
muy buen abogado de inmigration, y todo su despacho muy amables, y muy buena informacion!!! lo recom...
Facebook
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Apr 28, 2020,
(Translated by Google) Mr. Lozano is an amazing lawyer. He's so intelligent and caring. I can't than...
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Apr 24, 2020,
Fue mi abogado q me ayudó con el caso de mi esposo, se los recomiendo es un buen abogado de inmigrac...
Facebook
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Apr 3, 2020,
Great customer service and are willing to help right away!
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Feb 22, 2020,
I had a very good experience with this lawyer. I am rating it a 5 star rating, only for the outcome ...
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Feb 19, 2020,
I would like to thank the Lazano Law Firm for handling my wife's case. Everything went very well for...
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Jan 25, 2020,
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Jan 24, 2020,
Janethe Mata es la mejor, siempre me hizo sentir confianza.Todo muy bien buen servicio y atención gr...
Facebook
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Jan 24, 2020,
(Translated by Google) Excellent, work is inesplicable everything they did for me ... my most sincer...
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Dec 18, 2019,
Es un Abogado Recto y Formal Considerado y Justo, te Dice si oh no, no te tiene Dando Vueltas, Bendi...
Facebook
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Nov 17, 2019,
Was one of the best experiences working in this company! The staff was super friendly and always nic...
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Nov 15, 2019,
All experience is good with this law firm. My case is marriage-based green card after 3 years marria...
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Oct 30, 2019,
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Oct 25, 2019,
(Translated by Google) Alfredo and his team are really the best when it comes to immigration issues....
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Sep 30, 2019,
Best Immigration Attorney, Always on top of my case, really helpful and patient with all my question...
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Sep 3, 2019,
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Aug 25, 2019,
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Jul 28, 2019,
(Translated by Google) He is a good lawyer my case was lost and now I have a chance to have a better...
Google
The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC The Lozano Law Firm, PLLC
Scroll to Top